The call
This page is kept as part of the dated record. The order notes below describe the place as Roger recommended it, not as it operates today.
What to order
Best for
- Nothing Roger would recommend

Roger said this self-billed 'cocktail lounge' had no menu and a bartender who didn't know what a Sazerac was; his Old Fashioned came in a plastic cup, made in 20 seconds like a standard club drink.
Oxford Social Club is listed as closed. Roger's negative review of its cocktail program is kept as part of the record.
Yelp — Oxford Social Club listed as closed (checked 2026-09-17) (2026-09-17) ↗This page is kept as part of the dated record. The order notes below describe the place as Roger recommended it, not as it operates today.
From Roger’s Foursquare
They shouldn't label themselves as a "cocktail bar" when they don't have the proper mixology tools. And nearly every bartender didn't even know what certain cocktails were...
Posted
They shouldn't label themselves as a "cocktail bar" when they don't have the proper mixology tools. And nearly every bartender didn't even know what certain cocktails were....
Posted
Source-backed notes
Checked in 1 time on Yelp, most recently Apr 9, 2017. See the check-in log
“Billed itself as a 'cocktail lounge' on social media but no menu, bartender didn't know what a Sazerac was.”
Roger said the Old Fashioned came in a plastic cup and was made like a standard club drink in 20 seconds, calling it false advertising against the venue's Instagram presence.
Stay in the neighborhood

A low-key rooftop whiskey-cocktail bar above a Gaslamp hotel; Roger says the list is smaller than Whiskey House or Aero's but the Old Fashioned or Sazerac still hits, alongside tasty tater tots.

A family-owned Gaslamp taqueria Roger calls a great substitute for El Gordo, with more generous portions and carne asada, adobada, and birria all on point.

A Gaslamp French bakery Roger liked for its selection of sweets — macarons, pastries, and even a sour beer.