Cafe Coyote visit photograph by Roger Ma
Roger’s original visit photograph · 2009-08-09

Mexican

Cafe Coyote

Old Town, San DiegoRecommended

Roger rated this 4 stars, calling it by far the best restaurant on the main Old Town strip, with fresh tortillas, a loaded fish plate, and attentive, fast service, despite most of the surrounding strip being a tourist trap.

The call

Start with fish plate or burritos or carne fries or guacamole, and check the restaurant’s current menu before you go.

What to order

  • Fish plate
  • Burritos
  • Carne fries
  • Guacamole

Best for

  • Old Town Mexican food
  • A tourist-strip meal that's actually good

From Roger’s Foursquare

Roger’s tips on Cafe Coyote

On Roger’s lists: Carne Asada!.

Source-backed notes

Visit history

Checked in 10 times on Swarm, most recently Jun 13, 2020. See the check-in log

2009-08-09day precision · source explicit
★★★★☆
“This is by far the best restaurant on the main Old Town strip. Though I have to say pretty much all the spots here are tourist traps, this place has some pretty bomb food, servers are super attentive and everything comes out quite quick but not half-assed. Awesome quality food, tortilla was just fresh, texture and flavor was perfect! Fish plate was bombeezie, enough cheese, rice and beans to top it off! Thiugh the tortilla chips were ok and the salsa was ok, overall they hook it up here. My friends had burritos and carne fries and the guacamole was definitely hooked up fatty!!”

Roger called this the best restaurant on the main Old Town strip, praising fresh tortillas and a loaded fish plate with attentive, fast service, even though he considered most of the surrounding strip a tourist trap. (From an unpublished Yelp draft review, never posted publicly.)

Source 1 ↗

yelp

Stay in the neighborhood

More in Old Town.

All of Old Town →
Sushi Tadokoro visit photograph by Roger Ma
Roger’s pick$$$$
Old Town

Sushi Tadokoro

JapaneseSushi

One of the two omakase counters Roger named when asked where to take a visiting friend for sushi in 2022.

From the order notes
Omakase
Go for
A special sushi dinner · Letting the chef choose
Latest recordRecommended 2022
Churchill Cigar Lounge visit photograph by Roger Ma
RecommendedPrice varies
Old Town

Churchill Cigar Lounge

Cigars

Roger's pick for the best cigar lounge in town, where Glen pairs newcomers with a stick they won't regret and the humidor system is dialed in.

From the order notes
Cigar paired by Glen · Coffee or wine/beer
Go for
Cigar pairing guidance · A relaxed smoke with coffee or wine
Latest recorded visit2024
Casa Guadalajara visit photograph by Roger Ma
RecommendedPrice varies
Old Town

Casa Guadalajara

Mexican

On his first visit to this Old Town institution, Roger enjoyed the decor, roaming mariachis and a warm basket of fresh nacho chips brought out right away; despite a busy dining room, a server outside her own section still helped take and deliver their order, and his beef chimichanga with rice and beans had a good, fresh taste.

From the order notes
Beef chimichanga · Nacho chips
Go for
A lively group dinner with mariachis · Big portions meant to share
Latest recorded visit2007-09-28