The call
This page is kept as part of the dated record. The order notes below describe the place as Roger recommended it, not as it operates today.
What to order
- Oysters
Best for
- Happy hour oysters

Seafood · American
Roger rated this 4 stars, calling out happy hour oysters and noting that happy hour ran all day on Mondays at this La Jolla seafood-forward restaurant.
Herringbone's former domain (herringboneeats.com) now redirects to an unrelated hospitality company's generic venue page, and Herringbone does not appear on founder Brian Malarkey's current restaurant-group website (checked 2026-09-21) alongside its known sibling restaurants; current operating status could not be confirmed.
herringboneeats.com redirect and Puffer Malarkey Collective site check (2026-09-21) ↗This page is kept as part of the dated record. The order notes below describe the place as Roger recommended it, not as it operates today.
Source-backed notes
“HH oysters Hh all day Monday”
Roger flagged the happy hour oysters and noted that happy hour ran all day on Mondays. (From an unpublished Yelp draft review, never posted publicly.)
Stay in the neighborhood
Roger rated this 4 stars, calling the food, ocean view, and service all awesome even on a rainy day, and remembering a braised lamb dish.
A La Jolla Latin fusion restaurant Roger rated 4 stars for its polished-but-not-overdone decor, fast, friendly service, good music, and reasonable prices, remembering a huge mahi mahi burrito-style dish that filled him up before he got halfway through it.
A La Jolla juice spot Roger stopped into on a hot day while cruising around, rating it 4 stars after being amazed at how tasty and smooth the smoothie came out, with no artificial aftertaste.